Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 banner

News

Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216

  • Posted on
Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216

In this article, Danielle Peters, Head of Family Law at Crane & Staples LLP and Chair of Training for the Hertfordshire Family Justice Board (HFJB), examines the case of Re C and considers its potential implications for future Family Court proceedings.

On 30th September 2026, the Hertfordshire Local Family Justice Board Family Law Conference 2026 brought together more than 130 delegates to explore some of the most pressing issues affecting children and families today, including domestic abuse, coercive control and technology-facilitated harm. You can read more highlights and insights from the conference in this article.

What better way to sum up the conference than to hear commentary from Sir Stephen Cobb, who (with Lord Justice Moylan and Lord Justice Zacaroli), had only the day before handed down the highly anticipated Court of Appeal judgment in Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216.

It was a rare opportunity and a real privilege to hear directly from the President of the Family Division so soon after the judgment had been handed down, and to gain insight into the thinking behind a decision likely to have significant implications for the family justice system. We are grateful to Sir Stephen for taking the time to speak at the conference and for sharing his reflections on a judgment that is likely to shape future discussions surrounding domestic abuse, children's welfare and the Child Focused Court Model.

What Was Re C About?

The case examined the role of the new procedure for determining child arrangements for separated families under the new “Child Focused Court” model, designed to tackle failings in private law process in domestic abuse cases. The President expounded upon the necessity of the family courts to place children's welfare and safety at the forefront of its decision-making.

The Re C case concerned four siblings, two boys aged 14 (A) and 6 (D), and two girls aged 11 (B) and 9 (C). The mother's case was that the marriage was “characterised throughout by the father’s coercive and controlling behaviour, punctuated with acts of physical and emotional abuse towards her and the children”. The father admitted a number of acts of abuse towards the mother and children.

Contact orders made by Mr Justice McKendrick were challenged on appeal by the mother, as was an order under section 91(14) of the Children Act 1989. The mother succeeded in her appeal against the section 91(14) order insofar as it applied to her, but her appeals were otherwise dismissed.

Children's Welfare Remains Paramount

The President impressed upon the conference the necessity for children to be perceived by the courts as individuals and that nothing about the new model detracted from the principle that the welfare of a child must always be the court's paramount concern.

The CFC model is intended to create more investigative and less adversarial procedures and is designed to be more closely focused on the lived experience of children and victim-survivors of domestic abuse.

Practice Direction 12J should still be applied with the same rigour as before.

“The question is whether findings of fact are ‘necessary’ (per Re H-N: see §23 above) in order to provide a proper foundation for the assessment of future risk and for the welfare decisions. That exercise requires the court to identify the real issues in the case, to consider whether admissions already provide a sufficient factual platform, and to determine which, if any, disputed allegations actually require adjudication.” - Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 at [46].

Every case requires a robust and very careful case-specific analysis of the usual section 1(3) welfare checklist factors.

Children's Wishes and Feelings in the Context of Domestic Abuse

In this case, the Court of Appeal noted that all of the children were expressing clear and consistent wishes to see their father.

“The FCA recorded the children’s wishes and feelings in her report. To ascertain those wishes and feelings, she conducted with each of the children a structured exercise intended to facilitate the expression of their views. She recorded that A and C wished to see their father; B also expressed the view that she wished to see him, adding that she would wish for her father and mother to be on the same ‘island’ with all of her most treasured people and belongings, but ‘it must be a really big island so that they don’t see each other’. The FCA incorporated within her report a letter which B (then rising 11) had written for the Judge; it read:

‘Dear Judge, I have never written a proper letter before so this may be weird. I don’t mind seeing dad, I like it. I don’t mind how often I see him, I don’t have to see him all the time as long as I get to see him sometimes. Yours sincerely [B]’.”  - Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 at [75].

The Family Court Adviser nevertheless recommended to the court a termination of direct contact order, a recommendation which Mr Justice McKendrick did not adopt when making direct contact orders at the conclusion of the case at first instance:

“I, on balance, consider there are more emotional risks to the children by being denied contact with their father than it taking place in accordance with their wishes [and] feelings and being supervised by [JM].” - Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 at [95], quoting McKendrick J at [121].

 The Judge confirmed that he had carefully considered the harm the children had suffered, the risk of future harm and the effect of the father's admitted domestic abuse on both the children and their mother.

The Outcome

After careful analysis of all the relevant factors set out in the Children Act 1989, the Court of Appeal considered the operation of the Child Focused Court (CFC) model and upheld the Judge's welfare decision in respect of contact for these children.

Whilst ultimately the final order for contact was more restrictive than an earlier order, with direct face-to-face contact reduced and the requirement for telephone contact discharged, the Judge chose to depart from the recommendations of the Family Court Adviser, which recommended a cessation of all direct contact arrangements.

The Judge chose instead, and the Court of Appeal agreed, to continue face-to-face contact in a case where the children had expressed a continued wish to see their father.

In using the new CFC model, the Judge balanced the Cafcass 'no contact' recommendation with the children's wishes to provide a solution designed to keep the children safe while allowing contact to continue, ensuring that the children's best interests were served.

The President drew on the words of Wall LJ in Re S [2007] 1 FLR 819 in concluding:

“Provided the judge has carefully examined the facts, made appropriate findings in relation to them and applied the welfare check-lists contained in section 1(3) of the 1989 Act and section 1 of the 2002 Act, it is unlikely that this court will be able properly to interfere with the exercise of judicial discretion, particularly in a finely balanced case.” - Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 at [127], citing Re S [2007] 1 FLR 819 at [48].

Conclusion

The case provides practitioners with some important lessons:

  1. Section 7 reports and recommendations are to be used as a tool to guide and inform; they are not binding on the judiciary. When advising clients, practitioners should take care to challenge unsuitable conclusions where there is concern that they would not meet a child's needs.
  2. Taking a trauma-informed approach is not a "one-size-fits-all" solution. Each child's experience and circumstances will be different and, as such, it is necessary to take a nuanced approach.
  3. A parent who resists contact may have entirely reasonable grounds for adopting their protective position. If that is the case, a section 91(14) order would not be appropriate. The mother succeeded in this part of her appeal, where the trial judge had sought to make orders preventing her from making further applications.
  4. The case reflects the ambition of the CFC model to move away from an adversarial system that positions parents against one another, with an emphasis instead on an investigative process and problem-solving, child-focused solutions.

Contact Us

At Crane & Staples, our Family Law team is committed to providing thoughtful, compassionate and expert advice to families navigating complex and often sensitive issues. Led by Danielle Peters, the team continues to engage with developments in family law to ensure clients receive the highest standard of support and representation.

If you need advice or assistance with a family law matter, please get in touch with our Family Law team. We are here to provide clear, practical guidance tailored to your individual circumstances.

Join Our Family Law Team

Our Family Law team is currently growing, and we are looking for a Child Care Solicitor Advocate and Children Panel Member with 2+ years’ PQE to join our Public Law Care Team in Welwyn Garden City. This is an opportunity to join an experienced and supportive team undertaking complex and meaningful public law children work, with the opportunity to conduct your own advocacy and develop your career within a well-established Hertfordshire firm. If you are an experienced Children Panel member looking for your next opportunity, we would be delighted to hear from you.

    Get in touch





    Payments
    Fee Estimate